★★★★★ THE TWO QUESTIONS, ANSWERED — AND THE BIGGEST FIND YET
QUESTION 1: IS THERE A WARRANT?
NO — and now that is established four separate ways, all from the state's own paperwork.
The word "warrant" appears on the LEMS blood-draw form as a fillable field, and it is BLANK on the form. Every place a warrant could be recorded:
| Document | Warrant field | Status |
|---|
| DS-367 p1 (sworn Officer's Statement) | never mentions a warrant | absent |
| DS-367 p2 (narrative + Observation/Arrest) | — | BLANK, both |
| SBPD report 26-34514 (4pp, full narrative) | never mentions a warrant | absent |
| LEMS blood-draw form (both copies) | WARRANT # ________ | BLANK |
| LEMS | [ ] RESTRAINED/FORCED DRAW | NOT ticked |
So: warrantless, non-forced, and recorded as voluntary. That puts the entire draw on consent — and consent is the one exception that Arredondo and Ling say is the state's burden to prove on the totality.
And the consent evidence is thin: the DS-367 p2 DRIVER RESPONSE lines are blank — no verbatim words recorded. The only support is a checkbox ticking "Will you take a Blood Test?" and the report's single sentence "Once detained, Moreno agreed to provide a blood sample" — which also misnames him.
Combined with the 2026 timing (good-faith crutch unavailable), this is the motion.
---
QUESTION 2: THE MEDICAL RECORDS — AND THE KILLER FIND
The packet contains three separate injuries-denials and no hospital:
| Record | What it says |
|---|
| DS-367 p1 | no injury field; "Collision: ☒" only |
DUI Eval p1 Are you injured? | ☒ NO |
DUI Eval p2 Have you bumped your head? | ☒ NO |
Booking App Any Injuries or Illnesses? | ☒ NO |
Booking App Medical Examination Prior to Booking? | ☒ NO |
Booking App Hospital Where Treated | BLANK |
| LEMS form | kit says it's an alcohol draw; nothing medical |
★★★ THE DUI EVALUATION FORM CONTRADICTS ITSELF AGAINST HIM — AND IT'S NOTABLE
Page 1 records Corrective Lenses: ☒ Glasses — the officer DID note he wears glasses.
Page 1 also records: "Are you injured? ☒ No".
So Moya knew about the glasses and still ran HGN + Walk & Turn + One Leg Stand without checking whether they were worn. And he recorded "no injury" on a form he also marked Collision Related: ☒ YES.
★★★ THE EYE FINDINGS ARE WORSE THAN REPORTED — AND BETTER FOR HIM
DUI Eval page 2 is more precise than the report, and it captures the neurological picture:
Pupil Size: ☒ Equal
Horizontal gaze nystagmus present: ☒ Yes
Vertical nystagmus present: ☒ Yes ← the report said this too
Lack of convergence present: ☒ Yes
HGN Left Eye: Lack of smooth pursuit? ☒ Yes · HGN at maximum deviation? ☒ Yes
HGN Right Eye: Lack of smooth pursuit? ☒ Yes · HGN at maximum deviation? ☒ Yes
Angle of onset: [BLANK] degrees on BOTH eyes ← the two numbers NHTSA requires were never recorded
Vertical gaze nystagmus + bilateral lack of convergence = a neurological presentation, not a classic alcohol one. On a concussed man with a documented head strike. The officer wrote it down and charged alcohol anyway.
★★ THE WALK & TURN SELF-DESTRUCTS
DUI Eval p2, the same page:
Turn: ☐ Proper ☒ Improper (Explain): "LIFTED BOTH FEET OFF GROUND AND TURNED"
Maintained balance during instructions: BOTH BOXES LEFT UNCHECKED
Footwear: Work Boots ← footwear noted, glasses not
Then the score table (Stopped walking / Missed heel-toe / Stepped off line / Raised arms / Actual steps) is entirely BLANK — no numeric scoring on either the 1st or 2nd nine.
★★ THE PRELIMINARY BREATH TEST WAS NEVER DONE
DUI Eval page 3: PRELIMINARY BREATH TEST — Test No.1: Time __ B.A.C. __ / Test No.2: Time __ B.A.C. __ — all blank.
And VITAL SIGNS EXAMINATION (temperature, second pulse, BP) — all blank.
So no PAS, no vitals — on a DRE-style evaluation form, marked DRE Certified: ☒ No. A non-DRE officer ran a DRE form.
★★★ AND PAGE 4 — THE MIRANDA TIMING AND THE MISSING WATSON
DUI Eval p4 SUSPECT INTERVIEW:
Miranda: ☒ Yes · Time: 2220 · Location: CDC
What have you been drinking? NOTHING**
How much did you drink? NOTHING**
Are you under the care of a Doctor? ☒ No · Have you taken any medication? ☒ No
What have you been eating? YES BREAD SANDWICH · When did you eat? 3-4 HOURS AGO
Miranda was given at 2220 — ONE MINUTE AFTER the blood was drawn at 2219. The sample was taken before any interview, before any Miranda, and before anyone established whether he'd eaten/drunk/taken anything. He then said, twice, "NOTHING."
And the WATSON ADVISEMENT: Watson advisement given by: ☒ NOT GIVEN — with Reason for non-advisal: and the signature/date/ID fields left blank.
---
★★★★★ THE BIGGEST FIND: THE BLOOD KIT NUMBERS DON'T MATCH — AND ONE COPY IS EXPIRED
The packet contains two copies of the same LEMS form (the goldenrod tech copy and the pink agency copy — the form's own footer: "WHITE & YELLOW: LEMS / GOLDENROD: TECH/NURSE / PINK: AGENCY"). They should be carbon-identical. They are not.
| Field | Copy 1 | Copy 2 |
|---|
| Invoice No. | 373451 | 373451 |
| BA KIT # | 41117 | 46152 |
| EXPIRATION | 3/31/23 | 3/31/27 |
| Nurse/Tech | V. Vasquez CPT #559 | V. Vasquez CPT #339 |
| Violation ticked | (a) impaired + drug/addicted | (b) alcohol |
| LOCATION ticked | JAIL / CJC | CIC |
| AGENCY ticked | SBPD-ish | VPD |
| CASE/CITE# | 2308-34814M | 2308-34814M |
| NAME OF SUBJECT | "Cuellar, Gabriel" | "Cuellar, Gabriel" |
| DATE | 3/26/24 | 3/26/24 |
| CALL / ARRIVAL / PROC | 2150 / 2215 / 2219 | 2150 / 2215 / 2219 |
| #STICKS | blank | 1 |
Why each of these is serious
1. TWO DIFFERENT BLOOD KITS. 41117 vs 46152. If they're two kits, there were two tubes and the chain covers both — or one is a transcription error on a sworn form.
2. ★ AN EXPIRATION OF 3/31/23. If copy 1 is right, the kit expired 3/31/2023 — the draw was 3/26/2026, i.e. nearly three years out of date. Even the "in date" reading (3/31/27) means one of the two forms is wrong about the consumable's shelf life. Preservative efficacy is exactly what degrades, and degraded anticoagulant/preservative is precisely the fermentation mechanism in Klaus.
3. TWO DIFFERENT CPT NUMBERS for the same phlebotomist: #559 vs #339. The officer's report says #559.
4. A THIRD NAME VARIANT: the LEMS form says "Cuellar, Gabriel". The booking sheet says "GARRET DANIEL". The DS-367 says "GARRETT D". His name is Garrett. Now three spellings and a wrong first name.
5. ★ THE OFFICER'S "BLOOD KIT NUMBER" IS THE INVOICE NUMBER. Report: "Blood kit number is 373451." But 373451 is the LEMS invoice no., printed next to "INVOICE NO". The actual kits are 41117/46152. So the sworn report's kit identification points at the billing document, not the specimen.
6. Date is 3/26/24 on the LEMS form too — same 2024 error as the DS-367, and the DUI Eval pages, and the DA stamp.
7. Case no. on the LEMS form is "2308-34814M" — appearing nowhere else. Every other document says 2026-00034514.
8. Location/agency ticks disagree (JAIL/CJC vs CIC; SBPD vs VPD).
A chain-of-custody document that is not carbon-identical across its own copies, naming two different kits, two different phlebotomist IDs, an expired consumable, and a foreign case number, is the strongest Title 17 exhibit you will get. And it's not an argument — it's a physical document the DMV produced.
---
THE COMPLETE PICTURE NOW
Officer Moya: arrived to a scene CHP already controlled · did not see the driving or the collision · recorded "injured: NO" three times · noted glasses but didn't confirm worn · ran FSTs on a concussed man · ran a DRE form uncertified · recorded VGN + convergence failure but charged alcohol · took no PAS · recorded no FST scores and no HGN onset angles · left the sworn narrative blank · dated it 2024 · wrote two DOBs · called him "Moreno" and "Gabriel" · gave Miranda after the blood · ticked "Watson NOT given".
Blood: warrantless, not forced, consent evidenced only by a checkbox · drawn at a jail · 1 minute before Miranda · described as a "voluntary consent" form with the warrant field blank · kit numbers that don't match · one copy showing an expired kit · two phlebotomist IDs · no hospital, no medical exam.
And he told them "NOTHING" twice.
RANKED, FINAL
1. Suppression — blank sworn narrative; officer saw nothing; warrant field blank; force box unticked; consent unproven; Miranda post-draw
2. Title 17 chain/custody — mismatched kit numbers, expired kit, dual CPT, foreign case no.
3. Injury triplet + jail-not-hospital — Hughey
4. VGN + convergence + concussion — neurological, not alcoholic
5. Restriction B/glasses + blank FST scoring + missing HGN angles — FST invalidity
6. No PAS, no vitals, uncertified DRE
7. Identity/date integrity everywhere
Answer to the two questions: no warrant (four ways); medical records still not in the file, but the forms that would have flagged injury all say NO — which is itself the case.