BEST DEFENSE — HONEST RANKING (supersedes the "driving is the lead" claim)
After reading the actual text of Veh. Code §40300.5. You were right to push back.
---
⚠ FIRST: I OVERCLAIMED. The "no one saw you drive" point is largely DEFEATED.
I said nobody watching you drive was the lead. **It isn't — because you told them you were driving, and the
statute expressly removes the need for an officer to see it.**
Veh. Code §40300.5, verbatim:
> "*In addition to the authority to make an arrest without a warrant pursuant to paragraph (1) of
> subdivision (a) of Section 836 … a peace officer may, without a warrant, arrest a person when the
> officer has reasonable cause to believe that the person had been driving while under the influence** …
> when any of the following exists: (a) The person is involved in a traffic crash."*
Read that carefully — "In addition to the authority … pursuant to 836." It is a **separate, additional
power that bypasses the "presence" requirement. And §40300.6: §40300.5 "shall be liberally
interpreted**."
So the sequence that beats you is short:
1. There was a crash → §40300.5(a) applies on its face.
2. §40300.5 needs only reasonable cause to believe he had been driving — and **your own admission
supplies that** ("Cuellar stated he was driving").
3. Therefore the arrest was lawful, the presence rule in Mercer/Music never bites, and Element 1
stands.
*Why Mercer didn't save you: Mercer was asleep in a lawfully parked car with no crash*. The court
said in terms that the §40300.5 exceptions "did not apply … when, as here, a vehicle is lawfully parked."
You had a crash. The exception applies. Game over on that point.
**Honest status of the driving/Mercer point: real, but SECONDARY. It forces the officer to say the
admission out loud — it does not win Element 1.**
---
★ SO WHAT IS ACTUALLY THE BEST DEFENSE? THE BLOOD. That's what 3 of 5 models said and they were right.
Not the number (0.226 clears 0.08 whatever way you slice the tolerance). Two layers, in this order:
1. FOUNDATION / ADMISSIBILITY — the gateway attack (this is the strongest single point)
Make the Department prove the blood result is even admissible:
- Evid. Code §1280 — public-employee records exception; the DMV, as proponent, bears the burden of laying the foundation.
- **Burge v. DMV (1992) 5 Cal.App.4th 384, 389* — admissible only* if based on a public employee's personal first-hand knowledge.
- **Shea v. DMV (1998) 62 Cal.App.4th 1057 — an unsupervised forensic trainee is outside the scope of duty → falls outside §1280**.
- **Imachi v. DMV (1992) 2 Cal.App.4th 809, 816–817** — the report is presumptively valid, burden on the licensee to attack.
★ And the killer sub-question: does the DMV's packet even CONTAIN a lab report? The 4/28 and 4/30
DS 2044 indexes list Notice of Hearing · Driving Record/Arrest Report · DS 367 · Supplemental Report(s) —
no lab report, no toxicology, no LEMS paper. If none is marked as an exhibit on the day, **Element 3
has no evidence at all.** That is a W-I-N, not a point.
2. RELIABILITY / CHAIN — if the report does get in
Frame as unreliability, not technicality (Gerwig is the trap: a bare Title 17 breach is not
enough). Then **Davenport / Baker v. Gourley** shift the burden to the DMV.
- Kit 46152 on the forms vs "373451" (the LEMS invoice number) in the typed narrative → identity of the sample.
- No inversion recorded. ~7-month gap draw→test.
- Manriquez v. Gourley (2003) 105 Cal.App.4th 1227.
3. CREDIBILITY — cheap, don't oversell
The narrative calls you "Moreno." Booking says arrested 20:29 but the evaluation didn't start until
2046 — arrested before the tests that justified it. Avalos supplied the probable cause then filed
nothing. These go to weight, not to an element.
4. DRIVING / Mercer — secondary
Only bites if you can show §40300.5 is unavailable. It isn't, on a crash. Raise it; don't lead with it.
---
THE FIVE THINGS TO ACTUALLY DO
1. Read the blood report — exact value, method, matrix, uncertainty. (All models: "±0.09" is likely a misread.)
2. Confirm whether a lab report is in the DMV packet / gets marked as an exhibit. If not → Element 3: no evidence.
3. Demand the foundation chain — who drew it, certificate status, who analysed it, whether supervised.
4. Object at the outset on due process (Cal. DUI Lawyers Assn. v. DMV (2022) 77 Cal.App.5th 517) — preserves a writ.
5. Say everything on the record — writ review under §13559 is record-only.
**Blunt truth: you are the underdog, and the fight is over the STATE'S LAB PAPER, not over whether you were
driving. You told them you were driving. Believe your own account and attack their evidence instead.**