ONLINE RESEARCH — WHAT THE WEB SETTLED
Ran the case against the open web: court portal, LEMS corporate record, BD Vacutainer manufacturer specs, and the case law. Results below. Two of the five things I went looking for came back with new, material facts — and one of them is the best exhibit yet.
---
★★★★★ 1. THE BLOOD-DRAW FORM HAS THREE COPIES — AND ALL THREE DISAGREE
I'd found two (goldenrod + pink). There is a third (page 13 of the packet, a further LEMS copy). It is not a duplicate of either. Across the three copies of the same draw, the state has produced:
| Field | Copy A | Copy B | Copy C |
|---|
| BA KIT # | 41117 | 46152 | 46152 |
| EXPIRATION | 3/31/23 | 3/31/27 | 3/31/27 |
| Phlebotomist | V. Vasquez CPT #559 | V. Vasquez CPT #339 | V. Vasquez LVN 5591 |
| Call time | 2150 | 2150 | 21:00 |
| Arrival | 2215 | 2215 | 2213 |
| Violation ticks | (a) impaired + drug | (b) alcohol | neither (a) nor (b) |
| Location | JAIL / CJC | CIC | JAIL CIC |
| Agency | SBPD-ish | VPD | P.D. "SBD" |
| #STICKS | blank | 1 | 1 |
| Name | "Cuellar, Gabriel" | "Cuellar, Gabriel" | "Cuellar Garrett D" (correct) |
THE KILLER: her designation appears as CPT #559, CPT #339, and LVN 5591.
- CPT = Certified Phlebotomy Technician — a statutorily defined forensic draw credential.
- LVN = Licensed Vocational Nurse — a different licence class.
- And #559 vs #339 vs 5591 are three different identifier numbers.
V. Vasquez's qualification to take a Title 17 forensic blood draw is therefore unresolved on the face of the state's own documents. That is directly the Gerwig nexus question — and unlike Gerwig, where the phlebotomist was at least established as a phlebotomist, here the paperwork can't agree what she is.
The report says CPT #559. Copy C says LVN 5591. Those cannot both be right.
★★★★ 2. THE KIT EXPIRY — MANUFACTURER SPEC IS UNAMBIGUOUS
Copy A shows expiration 3/31/23; the draw was 3/26/26. BD's own Vacutainer instructions for use state, verbatim:
> "Do not use tubes after their expiration date. Tubes expire on the last day of the month and year indicated."
So on Copy A's own face the tube was ~3 years out of date. And BD's known failure mode is exactly this: a 2019 BD recall (lot 8187663, grey-top fluoride tubes) where the sodium fluoride preservative and potassium oxalate anticoagulant were missing entirely. BD's recall notice stated that for samples stored at room temperature longer than two days, the BAC determined may be falsely high or falsely low.
Note the timelines here: the blood was drawn at a jail, then "later stored as evidence at the San Bernardino Police Department" — and stayed undisclosed until 13 October, ~7 months later. If the tube's preservative was degraded (expired) and it sat unrefrigerated, the "falsely high" mechanism is live and it is Klaus almost word-for-word.
And the anticoagulant point cuts further: without working oxalate the sample clots; without fluoride, microbes ferment residual glucose into ethanol in the tube. Both inflate.
★★★ 3. LEMS IS REAL, CONTRACTED, AND ITS OWN FORM PROVES THE JAIL DRAW
Checked the company. Law Enforcement Medical Services, LLC (le-ms.net) — "24/7 DUI blood and urine collection services exclusively supporting law enforcement agencies." Named services include responding to "police departments, detention facilities, hospitals, and approved collection sites." A June 2026 city council agenda shows a police chief asking to authorise a LEMS contract, describing it as on-call phlebotomy for DUI that lets officers "avoid transporting subjects to medical facilities."
That last phrase is the whole case in one line. LEMS exists precisely so an officer doesn't take a bleeding, concussed driver to hospital. And LEMS's own form ticks LOCATION OF PROCEDURE/DRAW: [X] JAIL.
Precedent note: in Smith v. DMV (2014) the appellate record shows LEMS doing the draw and the specimen being "placed into the evidence at the lock up" — same pattern.
★★★★ 4. THE COURT HAS THE CASE — BUT NOT UNDER NUMBER 2026-00034514
Got into the San Bernardino Court Access Portal API (reverse-engineered: POST /api/cases/bycitation, GET /api/case/validate/{n}). Tried ~60 format variants. Every one returned "not found."
But the TR-130 Court Copy in the packet proves a case exists and gives:
- Court date: 08/17/26 at 8:00 AM — "ACT BY THIS DATE TO AVOID A WARRANT OR ADDED FEES"
- Agency Case Number: 20-34814 ← not 2026-00034514
- Citation No. 1111757 — also not found in CAP
So: the case is filed, you have a court date, and none of the numbers you've been given index it in CAP. That needs the clerk (909-384-1888, or the Fontana traffic district listed at 909-350-9322). Given the DS-367 is dated 2024, it is entirely plausible the court has it under a mismatched year prefix — the same year-error family as everything else.
★★★★★ 5. AND THE TR-130 NAMES AN ARRESTING OFFICER WHO APPEARS NOWHERE ELSE
The Court Copy lists two officers:
ARRESTING OR CITING OFFICER: R. YINGER · EMPLOYEE NO. 7574
ARRESTING OFFICER, (if different from above): T. LOPEZ · EMPLOYEE NO. 51615
R. Yinger / badge 7574 appears in no other document in the packet. The DS-367, the report, the DUI Eval, the booking form, the LEMS form — all say Lopez Moya, 51615 (and one LEMS copy says "L. Perez"). The citation — the charging instrument set for 8/17/26 — carries a fourth officer identity in the arresting-officer field.
Also on that citation, independently:
Insurance: [X] N ← no proof of insurance shown (a separate VC 16028 exposure, not on the DUI charges)
- DL:
F6244243 — versus F5244243 on every other document. Fifth identity inconsistency.
Reason for Stop: CFS - TRAFFIC COLLISION — confirms no observed driving; they were dispatched
Comments: NIGHT / CLEAR — night-time FSTs, and no lighting qualifier recorded against the eye test
[X] Collision with Correctable (Fix-It): [X] N
---
WHAT THE WEB DID NOT SETTLE
- No news article for the 26 March 2026 collision (Del Rosa/Marshall is a busy corridor; no press release picked it up).
- No CAP case record under any number tried.
- Medical records still not online — you must pull them from the hospital.
- No published case on expired Vacutainer tubes specifically — the authority is BD's IFU + the 2019 recall + Klaus on the fermentation mechanism.
CASE LAW RE-CHECKED
- Smith v. DMV (2014) — LEMS draw, blood to lock-up evidence, lab report admitted on business-records affidavit. DMV-favourable.
- Monaghan v. DMV (1995) — DMV need not produce the analyst at the APS hearing. So don't expect live lab testimony; attack the documents.
- Which is exactly why the three-copy discrepancy matters: with no live witness, the paperwork is the evidence, and it contradicts itself.
---
CONSOLIDATED NEW FINDINGS
1. Three copies of the blood form, mutually inconsistent — kits, expiry, dates, times, location, agency, violation ticks, and the phlebotomist's credential class and number.
2. Expired tube on one copy — BD says do not use past expiry; BD's recall says preservative loss → falsely high/low BAC.
3. LEMS's business model is "don't take them to hospital" — their own form ticks JAIL.
4. Court date 08/17/26 exists, but under a different case number (20-34814) that CAP still doesn't index.
5. A fourth officer — "R. YINGER, 7574" — is named as the arresting officer on the charging citation.
6. Fifth DL variance (F6244243) and no insurance noted.
Add these to the standing list: blank sworn narrative, officer saw no driving, no warrant, no forced-draw tick, injury denied three times, jail-not-hospital, VGN + convergence, glasses known but not checked, no PAS, no FST scores, no HGN angles, Miranda after the draw, no Watson, 2024 dating, two DOBs, three surnames.
Artifacts: discovery/ (8 files incl. DS2044_APR28.pdf), FINDINGS.md, WARRANT-AND-MEDICAL.md, this file.