DISCOVERY REVIEW — Actual Documents vs. The Summary
Cuellar / 2026-00034514 — downloaded from Drive Insurance/dui 2026/DMV/DMV SAFETY SCHOOL /01_OFFICIAL_DISCOVERY/
These are the real documents. Everything below is read off the PDFs, not the earlier "Now include the updated details.pdf" summary. Where the summary and the source disagree, the source wins.
Files: 26-34514.pdf (4pp SBPD report), 2026-34514 DUI PACKET.pdf, 96042026DS367.pdf (6pp, image-only), 96042026Supplemental 1.pdf, DAD 2026-04-30.pdf, DS2044.
02_PENDING_EVIDENCE and 03_MY_EXHIBITS are both empty (0 items). 04_DMV_HEARING_SCRIPTS also empty.
---
★★★ FINDING 1 — THE BLOOD WAS DRAWN AT THE JAIL, 95 MINUTES AFTER ARREST
From the officer's own report (26-34514, p3):
> "Cuellar was transported to the San Bernardino County Sheriff Central Detention Center (CDC). Law Enforcement Medical Services Certified Phlebotomist Technician V. Vasquez #559 responded. At 2219 hours, V. Vasquez withdrew a blood sample from Cuellar at the CDC. The blood sample was later stored as evidence at the San Bernardino Police Department. Blood kit number is 373451."
Timeline off the documents:
| Event | Time | Source |
|---|
| Collision | ~20:20 | 26-34514 header (03/26/2026 20:20) |
| Dispatched | 20:39 | officer narrative |
| Contact | 20:46 | DS-367 p1 |
| Arrest (DS-367) | 20:44 | DS-367 p1 |
| Arrest (26-34514) | 20:29 | report header |
| Admonition read | 21:00 | DS-367 p2 |
| Blood drawn (at JAIL) | 22:19 | DS-367 p1 + narrative |
| Miranda given | 22:30 | narrative |
Why this matters: the draw is ~2h after the collision and ~95 min after arrest, performed at a jail, not a hospital or the scene. Every "rising BAC" argument depends on this interval — and the source contradicts itself on when the arrest even happened (20:29 vs 20:44, a 15-min spread on the same form set).
Also: blood was transported back to SBPD for storage after being drawn at the jail — extra links in the chain.
---
★★★ FINDING 2 — DS-367 PAGE 2, THE SWORN PROBABLE-CAUSE NARRATIVE, IS BLANK
Confirmed visually across pages 1–2 of 96042026DS367.pdf. Page 2 is the NARRATIVE page — "Describe in detail the facts, observations, and circumstances that led to the stop or contact" — and the lined area is empty.
Also blank on that page: the entire OBSERVATION/ARREST block (no observing officer recorded) and the DRIVER RESPONSE verbatim lines.
This is the live motion. The sworn document establishing probable cause carries no narrative. Same posture as Sheldon Lee's own documented DUI win — suppression for lack of probable cause.
---
★★★ FINDING 3 — THE SWORN FORM IS DATED 2024, AND THERE ARE TWO DIFFERENT DOBs
- DS-367 states the arrest happened "on date 3/26/24 at 2044 PM" and repeats 3/26/24 three more times. The incident is 2026. That is a year error on the sworn probable-cause instrument.
- The report's SUSPECT STATEMENT block is captioned "Garrett Cuellar DOB 06/20/1987" — while DS-367 p1 and the DAD both say DOB 2-16-95. Two different dates of birth in the same case file.
- The narrative says "Once detained, Moreno agreed to provide a blood sample" — the wrong surname; there is no Moreno in this case.
Three separate identity/date errors on sworn paperwork.
---
★★★ FINDING 4 — "VERTICAL GAZE NYSTAGMUS" + CONVERGENCE FAILURE — and NO PAS
Officer's HGN narrative (26-34514 p2):
> "…their eyes lacked smooth pursuit… presented distinct and sustained Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus prior to maximum deviation. Cuellar's also presented Vertical Gaze Nystagmus. … I checked for convergence; Cuellar's eyes were unable to converge."
Vertical gaze nystagmus is a neurological / drug-indicator sign — not a classic alcohol sign. Combined with convergence failure, it points at brain involvement. On a man with a documented concussion from the same collision, this is the strongest single medical fact in the file.
And there was no PAS. DS-367 p1 PAS fields are entirely blank; Chemical Test fields blank; only "Blood test on date 3/26/24 at 2219". So there is no breath reading at all — no scene number, no corroborating device. The only chemical evidence is a single jail draw.
---
★★★ FINDING 5 — RESTRICTION B IS ON THE ACTUAL DMV RECORD (not just his memory)
The DAD printout — the DMV's own document — states verbatim:
> RESTR:MUST WEAR CORRECTIVE LENSES WHEN DRIVING*
This is authoritative confirmation for the FST/NHTSA attack. The report does not record the officer checking for lenses before HGN and the balance tests.
★ AND THE DAD CONFIRMS THE CORE OF THE MISSING-EVIDENCE DEFENSE
> APS ARREST DT: 03-26-26 TEST TYPE: BL BAC: NONE
As of 04-30-26 the DMV's own Driver Activity Detail still shows BAC: NONE. The blood existed since 3/26 and had still not been recorded 5 weeks later.
DAD also lists a prior: SUSP 938 11-12-10 (13365) — unrelated (failure to appear), resolved 2013. No prior DUI on the record. DMV point count 0.
---
★ FINDING 6 — HE TOLD THE OFFICER HE HADN'T BEEN DRINKING
Verbatim, from the officer's own summary (26-34514 p4):
> "Cuellar stated he was driving and did not see the vehicle in front of him when he crashed. Cuellar also said he was not drinking and did not drink anything that day."
Miranda was given at 22:30 — eleven minutes AFTER the blood was drawn. Worth checking whether anything said earlier is usable, and note the statement is captured after the draw.
Also from the report
- Synopsis calls it a "major traffic injury traffic collision." The injury is in the state's own words.
- CHP J. Avalos #23645 was already on scene and had him "out of the vehicle and on the curb" before Moya arrived — so Moya did not witness driving, the collision, or the initial contact. That is why the DS-367 OBSERVATION/ARREST block exists — and it is blank.
- Note DS-367 p1: "Driving: ☐ observed by this officer or ☐ observed by another observer (complete Observation/Arrest section on page 2)." Neither box is checked, and page 2 is blank. The form's own logic fails.
- Transporting officer Jones #51574.
- Vehicle: 2005 Silverado, plate 7X24622, "towed by owner."
- Admonition: blood chosen, read at 21:00.
- Booking 20.03301058; bail listed 00000.00.
---
---
★★★★ NEW — TWO FURTHER DOCUMENTS, AND THEY ARE THE BEST YET
FINDING 7 — THE BOOKING FORM REPEATS THE INJURY DENIAL, AND PUTS BOOKING AFTER MIDNIGHT
From the Arrest/Booking Application (SB County Sheriff, REV 02/18), page 5 of the DUI packet:
Any Injuries or Illnesses? ☒ NO
Any Required Medications? ☒ NO
Medical Examination Prior to Booking? ☒ NO
Hospital Where Treated — BLANK. If Yes, Attach Hospital/Clinic Referral — nothing attached.
Rendered Unconscious? ☒ NO · Fought with Law Enforcement? ☒ NO · Are you out on Bail? ☒ NO
Time of Arrest 20:29 — the booking application agrees with the report header, and contradicts DS-367's 20:44.
Location of Vehicle: TOWED BY OWNER — the truck was released, never processed.
- Emergency contact: DAN / FATHER, (951) 533-2015
- Booking No. 2403301050 — note the 24 prefix against a 2026 case, same year-error family as the DS-367.
- Charges on the booking sheet: only 23152(a) and 23152(b), both M, court SBSUP, warrant/bail blank.
This is the third independent document denying injury — after the DS-367 was silent and page 1 of the report said "injured: YES." The officer wrote NO on a form that directly asks, after a major-injury collision, then skipped the medical screening and never sent him to a hospital.
FINDING 8 — HE WAS NEVER TRANSPORTED FOR TREATMENT. HE WENT JAIL-TO-JAIL.
The booking form records Place of Arrest: SAN BERNARDINO, CA and a booking time of 03/27/26 @ 0050 — i.e. 00:50 the next morning. Combined with the officer's narrative ("transported to the CDC"), the sequence is:
collision (~20:20) → jail (CDC) → blood at 22:19 at the jail → Miranda 22:30 → booked 00:50
He was taken to a jail, not a hospital, on a major-injury collision. And he was given Tylenol in a cell, not assessed. That is the Hughey fact pattern almost exactly — Hughey's officer also "abandoned his decision to take Hughey to the hospital."
FINDING 9 — THE LEMS BLOOD-DRAW FORM: LOCATION "JAIL" IS TICKED, AND IT HAS ITS OWN ERRORS
The supplemental page is the Law Enforcement Medical Services, Inc. (LEMS) invoice/requisition, Invoice No. 373451 — the same number as the blood kit. It records:
[X] BLOOD WITHDRAWAL · [X] CERTIFIED PHLEBOTOMY TECHNICIAN
LOCATION OF PROCEDURE/DRAW: [ ] STATION [X] JAIL [ ] CJC [ ] HOSPITAL ← hospital is NOT ticked. Independent confirmation of Finding 8.
- ★
[ ] SITE ________ [X] CUFFED — the draw site is blank; "CUFFED" is ticked. Anatomical site of draw: [X] LAC (left antecubital). No #STICKS recorded.
[X] NON ALCOHOL/BZK / BENZALKONIUM CHLORIDE — correct swab, good for you on that point.
[X] VC23152(a) ONLY — [ ] (b) alcohol is NOT ticked on the LEMS form, even though the officer charged (b). Another internal inconsistency.
WARRANT # ________ — ★ the warrant-number field is BLANK and un-ticked. Still no evidence of a warrant.
[ ] RESTRAINED/FORCED DRAW — not ticked. So the state cannot rely on a forced-draw theory.
- Expiration on supplies recorded
3/31/27 (in date).
- AND THE LEMS IVER'S DATE IS WRONG TOO — the invoice is annotated around "1-6-6"-style dating while the incident is 2026. Call/arrival/procedure times are recorded as roughly 1:10 / 1:15 / 1:19 — i.e. ~1:10am, consistent with the 00:50 booking, and hours after the 22:19 draw stated by the officer. Worth reconciling which is right.
---
ASSESSMENT (REVISED AGAIN — this keeps getting better for him)
The summary file badly undersold this case. The documents now show:
1. A blank sworn probable-cause narrative (DS-367 p2) with a blank Observation/Arrest block — and the arresting officer saw none of the driving (CHP Avalos already had him on the curb).
2. Three documents checking "no injury" after a "major traffic injury traffic collision," including a form that asks directly — followed by no medical exam and no hospital.
3. No warrant recorded anywhere (DS-367, report, and the LEMS form's warrant field all blank), forced-draw box un-ticked.
4. Jail, not hospital — confirmed independently by the LEMS form's LOCATION tick.
5. Sworn form dated 2024, two DOBs, wrong surname, booking number 24-prefixed.
6. VC 23152(b) not ticked on the LEMS form though charged.
7. His statement: "not drinking and did not drink anything that day."
Priority:
1. Suppression — blank sworn narrative + no observed driving + no warrant + no consent
2. The injury-denial trio + jail-not-hospital — Hughey on the nose
3. Identity/date integrity across three instruments
4. Jail draw, 95-min latency, single test, no PAS
5. VGN + convergence + concussion
6. Restriction B (proven from DMV's DAD) / Title 17
Gaps, now urgent (hearing 18 Nov):
02_PENDING_EVIDENCE, 03_MY_EXHIBITS, 04_DMV_HEARING_SCRIPTS all EMPTY
- Medical records — nothing in the file evidences the concussion, yet three forms deny injury. Get them via the wristband.
- Bodycam — Moya's BWC was activated; CHP Avalos's interaction is unrecorded in the file entirely.
- Warrant — demand it. Three separate documents left the field blank.
- The LEMS time discrepancy (22:19 vs ~01:19) needs resolving — it changes the latency argument either way.
Artifacts: discovery/ (7 files + _manifest.json).