★ THE LEAD ARGUMENT — verified from the narrative itself
Pulled 15 Nov 2026 from the typed SBPD narrative in 01_OFFICIAL_DISCOVERY__26-34514.pdf (real text layer).
This is the strongest thing in the file and it is now documented, not hypothetical.
---
1. NO OFFICER OBSERVED HIM DRIVING — it rests on his own admission alone
Verbatim from Officer Lopez Moya's own narrative:
> "At approximately 2039 hours, I was dispatched to Del Rosa and Marshal, reference a major traffic collision."
> "Prior to my arrival, the California Highway Patrol (CHP) (J. Avalos #23645) had the subject out of the vehicle and on the curb because the collision was on the border line."
> "Once I arrived, I observed a pickup truck on the side of the road with damage to the front…"
And how is driving established? Only this:
> "The driver admitted driving his vehicle."
> "Cuellar stated he was driving and did not see the vehicle in front of him when he crashed."
Nobody — not Lopez Moya, not CHP Avalos — is recorded as having seen the truck move.
2. Why that is legally powerful
- A warrantless misdemeanour arrest needs the offence committed in the officer's presence (Pen. Code §836).
- **Mercer v. DMV (1991) 53 Cal.3d 753 (Supreme Court, 6–1): a stationary vehicle with engine running = not driving; driver thus not lawfully arrested**, and cannot be subjected to the suspension statutes.
- **Music v. DMV (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 841*: requires movement of "at least a few inches*" in the officer's presence.
- Lawful arrest is required by the elements themselves — §13557(b)(3), via §13558(c)(2), and Mercer at 757.
- Gikas v. Zolin: no exclusionary remedy at APS — so frame it as "Element 1 (and 2) not established," never "suppressed."
3. ⚠ THE COUNTER YOU MUST PRE-EMPT — and the hole in it
The DMV's answer is Veh. Code §40300.5: warrantless arrest is fine, "notwithstanding any other
provision of law," where the person was (1) involved in a traffic accident — and §40300.6 says that
section is "liberally interpreted." There was a collision, so they will run this.
But §40300.5 is not free-standing proof of driving. Its own words require reasonable cause to believe
the person "had been driving." So it excuses the presence requirement; it does not independently
supply driving. Read properly, §40300.5 moves the question to:
> is an uncorroborated admission, made to police while detained, sufficient to prove driving?
That is the argument. And note Music is the case where the officer's own concession ("you did not
have reason to believe he was driving") sank the arrest.
4. Two more defects in the same narrative — both free
**(a) The case is investigated by an officer who did not file a report — that is why the DS-367 narrative
is blank. CHP Officer J. Avalos #23645** had Garrett out of the vehicle and supplied the probable-cause
account ("CHP advised me the driver appeared to be under the influence"), then Avalos filed nothing.
The sworn DS-367 is Lopez Moya's — and Lopez Moya's narrative is empty. Avalos is named but absent.
(b) The narrative names a stranger: "Once detained, _Moreno_ agreed to provide a blood sample."
In a Cuellar case, in the key blood paragraph. Either a cut-and-paste from another report or an
unexplained party. Ask who Moreno is.
(c) The dispatch itself didn't identify his vehicle: "the call stated that there was a Nissan kick*
[Juke] and a unknown vehicle pulled over to the side of the road."
(d) Time-of-arrest inconsistency: the booking application records time of arrest 20:29, but the
evaluation started at 2046 and FSTs followed. So the record has him **arrested before the tests that
supplied the probable cause.** Worth asking which is right.
5. THE THREE QUESTIONS TO ASK ON THE RECORD (short, calm)
1. "Officer, did you personally see my vehicle in motion before it stopped?"
2. "Did CHP Officer Avalos see it moving? He's not here and filed no report — is there any record of it?"
3. "Set against §40300.5: apart from my own statement, what evidence is there that I was driving?"
**If the answer is nothing, then Element 1 falls — and lawful arrest is also an element, so the arrest
falls with it.**
---
6. REVISED PRIORITY (this now leads)
1. *★ Driving / lawful arrest — Mercer, §40300.5* → verified from the narrative; nobody observed driving.
2. Blood: foundation then reliability (Burge, Shea, Imachi, then Gerwig, Davenport).
3. Record-only on any writ (§13559) → say everything out loud at the hearing.
Do not lead with the blank narrative as an abstraction — lead with the fact it proves: no one saw you drive.