HEARING OUTLINE v2 — POST-BLOOD-RESULTS
Case 2026-00034514 · DMV APS hearing Wed 18 Nov 2026, 15:30 (Teams)
Hearing Officer Maria Salazar · direct 916-818-5319 · DL F5244243
> Why v2 exists. The May 21 outline was built on "the DAD shows BAC: NONE and no toxicology report exists." Both statements are dead. The DMV produced BLOOD RESULTS CUELLAR,G.pdf on 13 Oct 2026. If you argue Element 3 the old way you get corrected live.
---
THE RE-PRIORITISATION — read this before anything else
Blood result: BAC 0.226 ± 0.09 ÷ 100. (Draw 22:19; driving 20:29 — about 1 h 50 m between.)
That number is comfortably over 0.08, so:
| Element | Old plan (May) | New plan (now) |
|---|
| 1 — Reasonable cause / lawful arrest | one of three | ★ YOUR WIN CONDITION |
| 2 — Valid chemical test / consent | check admonition | Hughey — incapacity |
| 3 — BAC ≥ 0.08 | "no report exists" → win | not the number — attack the CHAIN |
Say it plainly to yourself: you do not need to beat 0.226. You need to make an element fail. You have two good elements to work with. Element 1 is the strongest.
What 0.226 honestly is and isn't:
- Isn't a number you can argue under 0.08. Rising BAC buys ~0.02 at most (→ ~0.20). Helpful colour, not a win.
- Is a number whose ± 0.09 is unusually wide — make the Department state the actual reported figure and its stated uncertainty and method (serum vs whole blood, headspace GC vs enzymatic). A vague report is attackable.
- Is a number that arrived 7 months late — which is itself an argument (see Chain, below).
---
ELEMENT 1 — YOUR LEAD. Push hard.
A. The DS-367 sworn narrative is BLANK
The DS-367 Officer's Statement is the Department's primary sworn evidentiary document. The narrative section — the only place the officer was required to set out the factual basis — is empty.
> "The narrative section of the Department's own sworn statement is entirely blank. There are no facts in the document on which this officer can found reasonable cause. Element 1 fails."
B. The FSTs were administered to a vision-restricted driver
- Officer's own evaluation form: "Corrective Lenses: NONE."
- DMV's own DAD printout: "RESTR: MUST WEAR CORRECTIVE LENSES WHEN DRIVING."
- Temp licence (4/28/26): corrective-lens box ticked.
HGN is an eye test; walk-and-turn and one-leg-stand rely on visual focal points. The officer recorded the restriction as absent, so the tests were not administered in the NHTSA standardised manner.
> "The officer certified that no corrective lenses were involved, when the Department's own record makes them mandatory. Eye-based and balance tests given to a vision-impaired subject are not standardised, and cannot establish probable cause."
C. The injury point — corrected. It is NOT a contradiction.
My earlier claim was wrong. The form does not say "injured: YES". Per the Case Summary (lines 65–71,
which had it right before I broke it):
- The scene form ticks Corrective Lenses: "Glasses" (not "None") — and per the form's own options
that means he uses glasses, not that he was wearing them.
- He self-reported "No" to "are you injured" — on both the scene form and the booking form.
So there is no same-officer-two-opposite-answers contradiction. What you actually have is:
1. Officer ticked "Glasses" but never recorded whether they were worn. Garrett says they were on
the dash. The form has no "prescribed but not being worn" option, so the officer didn't check.
That is a recording gap, and it is a weight point against the balance tests — nothing more.
2. Self-reported "No" is weak evidence where the injury is a suspected concussion — the whole
point of a concussion is that you mis-assess in the moment. Needs a medical record to land.
---
ELEMENT 2 — HUGHEY. This is where the head injury properly lands.
**Hughey v. DMV (1991) 235 Cal.App.3d 752 — published win on near-identical facts, won at the DMV: collision, head trauma, unhelmeted, marked intoxication symptoms, officer took the driver to a jail cell instead of hospital, next-day skull fracture found. The officer's on-scene judgment was not determinative; suspension set aside**.
The court's own words, worth reading to the officer:
> "Serious injury to the head, even though not causing sustained unconsciousness, may nevertheless render the injured person incapable of refusal."
> "Nor is the police officer a neurologist … incapability engendered by trauma wherein the symptoms are similar to those of intoxication will likely be missed by the officer absent a medical examination."
Apply it: a driver incapable of refusal by reason of head trauma was not validly admonished / did not validly consent → the chemical test itself is compromised. Backed by the phlebotomist repeatedly asking if you were okay and pressing Tylenol — an independent medic noticing what the officer discounted.
Check before the hearing: was the admonition box actually filled on the DS-367? Earlier reads suggested it was blank. If blank → Element 2 collapses too.
---
ELEMENT 3 — NOT the number. The CHAIN.
Lead case: **Gerwig v. Gordon (2021) 61 Cal.App.5th 59 — the limit. It held that proving a Title 17 violation is not enough by itself; you must show the violation raises a reasonable inference the result is unreliable*. Phillips v. Gordon (2023) is the burden-shift: once you show standards were in any respect not observed*, the burden moves to the DMV to prove reliability.
So do not list technicalities — argue unreliability.
Concrete, checkable defects already in the file:
1. The kit number does not exist in one place. The LEMS forms and the barcode sticker read 46152 / BB46152. The typed SBPD narrative says "Blood kit number is 373451" — and *373451 is the LEMS invoice number*, printed on the form header. One number, two roles.
2. No inversion recorded — inversion is what dissolves the preservative/coagulant into the sample, and it is the very thing Phillips relied on to prove the powder was preservative and not contaminant.
3. ~7-month gap draw → reported. Preservative and storage conditions between draw and testing are exactly what a Title 17 chain is meant to fix.
4. Two kit/invoice numbers live in the same packet, so which tube this case's sample came from is not nailed down.
5. The tube itself — ask what the lab received, keyed to which number, and who signed it in.
> "The Department must show the sample tested is the sample drawn. On this paperwork the kit is 46152 and the narrative calls it 373451 — the invoice number. Where the chain cannot be tied, the Department has not proved the reliability of the figure it relies on, and under Gerwig and Phillips that inference runs to me."
Also ask the Department to state: the actual reported figure, the stated uncertainty (± 0.09 is wide), the method, and whether the value is serum or whole blood. Answer on the record.
---
ORDER OF PLAY ON THE DAY
1. Continuance first (grounds below). If granted → you're out. If refused → no loss, proceed.
2. Opening (≤2 min) — Element 1 first: blank narrative, then the vision/FST point, then the injury contradiction.
3. Object on the record to the Department's exhibits on each of the three elements as they're offered.
4. Hughey / capacity on Element 2.
5. Chain on Element 3 — 46152 vs 373451, no inversion, 7 months.
6. Closing (≤1 min): "Three elements. The narrative is blank, the tests were non-standard, and the chain does not tie the tested sample to this draw. Any one is sufficient."
Attend whatever happens. A requested hearing you don't show = you lose by default.
---
CONTINUANCE GROUNDS — if you still want one
Ask today, in writing, to the Driver Safety office and laddsfresnooffice@dmv.ca.gov; then phone 916-818-5319.
> Hearing Officer Salazar — I respectfully request a continuance of 18 November.
> The Department produced further discovery on 13 October 2026 (the toxicology report) which the April production did not contain. Element 3 turns wholly on that late document and I have not had a fair opportunity to review it. The good cause arose on 13 October and this request is made promptly. No party is prejudiced.
If refused → 10 working days to seek judicial review (Gov. Code § 11524(c)) or you are barred. From 18 Nov that is about 2 Dec 2026, minus Thanksgiving. Write it down the moment they say no.
---
WHAT TO HAVE OPEN
DS-367 (blank narrative) · Eval Report p.1 (injured YES / lenses NONE) · Booking App p.5 (injuries NO) · DAD 4/30/26 (RESTR: corrective lenses) · LEMS copies (kit 46152) · typed narrative ("kit number is 373451") · the 13 Oct blood-result file.
HONEST SCORECARD
You are the underdog — 0.226 is a real number and Element 3 is survivable for the DMV. But you have two genuinely attackable elements (1 and 2) and the Department's own paper supplies both. Hughey is a published DMV win on your facts. This is winnable. Go in on Element 1.