★★★★★ THE CHP 555 TRAFFIC CRASH REPORT — THE DOCUMENT THAT CHANGES EVERYTHING

Added to Drive 2026-11-14 06:07 as SBPD/26 34514.pdf. 6 pages. Image-only scan (no text layer) — render + read.

CHP 555 Traffic Crash Report, pp1–5, prepared by Officer JONES #51574, reviewed by Chad Holgate 07/02/2026.

Packet also contains the DMV's DS 2393 "Request for APS Records" (Sierra R. Chavez, 4/30/2026) which asked SBPD specifically for the Collision Report — this is the document that request produced.

---

★★★★★ 1. THE INJURIES IN THIS COLLISION BELONG TO THE OTHER CAR — AND GARRETT IS RECORDED AS UNINJURED BY EVERYONE

NUMBER INJURED: 2 — and the narrative names who they are:

> "California Highway Patrol Officer J. Avalos #23645 responded first to the call for service and advised no party involved sustained serious injury. Although, D2 had a complaint of pain to her chest and back, and D2's passenger had a complaint of pain to her right arm."

Neither of those two is Garrett. D2 is the other driver. CHP p3 (INJURED/WITNESS/PASSENGERS) lists two female rows — 23 and 49 — matching D2 (DOB 2/14/2003 ⇒ 23) and her passenger. Garrett does not appear on the injured list at all.

So it is now five documents denying he was hurt:

1. DUI Eval p1 Are you injured? ☒ NO

2. DUI Eval p2 Have you bumped your head? ☒ NO

3. Booking App Any Injuries or Illnesses? ☒ NO

4. Booking App Medical Exam Prior to Booking? ☒ NO

5. CHP Crash Report — not on the injured list

And yet, on the state's own crash report, for HIS vehicle:

Airbag deployment + major damage + a two-person-injury collision — and he is the only uninjured person on the form. That is the Hughey argument supplied by the state, in the state's handwriting.

---

★★★★ 2. FAULT AND THE SPEED FINDING — AND HIS OWN STATEMENT EXPLAINS IT

CHP narrative, verbatim:

> "In summary, D1 was traveling southbound on N. Del Rosa Avenue toward the intersection of N. Del Rosa Avenue and E. Marshall Boulevard. At this time D2 was stopped at the intersection… preparing to proceed straight southbound through the intersection. Before D2 could proceed straight D1 rear ended D2 at a high rate of speed."

CAUSE (officer's conclusion):

> "…D1 was in violation of CVC 23152(a) - D.U.I Alcohol and 23152(b) - D.U.I >.08, additionally a secondary violation factor of CVC 22350 - Unsafe Speed."

This is the first document that assigns him fault AND adds a speeding factor. A new exposure the arrest report never mentioned.

But the defence writes itself from his own statement. He told Moya: "he was driving and did not see the vehicle in front of him when he crashed." Rear-ending a stopped car you didn't see, while legally required to wear corrective lenses, in a truck whose airbag deployed —

"Did not see" is a vision story, and Restriction B is on his licence. The officer noted Corrective Lenses: ☒ Glasses on the DUI eval — then ran the eye test without confirming they were worn. Nobody ever checked. The crash cause and the FST failure now share one innocent explanation: he couldn't see.

Also: Garrett rear-ended a car that was stationary. Under §23152(a) the state must show impairment affecting his driving. "High rate of speed into a stopped car" is impairment-flavoured — but also consistent with a man who didn't see it.

---

★★★★★ 3. PROBABLE CAUSE ORIGINATED WITH A CHP OFFICER WHO IS NOWHERE IN THE SWORN PAPERWORK

The chain, from CHP's own narrative:

> "Officers were notified by Ofc. Avalos that D1 may be under the influence of alcoholic beverages. Officer T. Lopez conducted a D.U.I. evaluation and determined D1 to be under the influence…"

So the entire reasonable-suspicion basis was supplied by CHP Officer J. Avalos #23645 — relayed second-hand. And on the DS-367:

Moya witnessed neither the driving nor the collision. Now the crash report confirms the basis for the stop/DUI investigation came from Avalos — who filed nothing. On the DMV track, where no live witness attends (Monaghan), the probable cause is a relayed narrative with a blank sworn form behind it.

---

★★★★ 4. THE OFFICER COUNT IS NOW FIVE — AND TWO HAVE NEVER APPEARED BEFORE

OfficerIDRoleAppears where
J. Avalos#23645CHP — first on scene, gave the DUI basisCHP 555 only
T. Lopez Moya#51615SBPD — DUI eval, arrest, DS-367everywhere
Jones#51574SBPD — DCU + PREPARED THE CHP CRASH REPORTreport + CHP 555
R. Yinger#7574wrote the TR-130 citation as "ARRESTING OR CITING OFFICER"TR-130 only
Chad Holgate—REVIEWER of the crash report, 07/02/2026CHP 555 only

Avalos, Yinger and Holgate appear in no other document. The citation's arresting-officer field names a man (Yinger) who filed nothing; the probable cause came from a man (Avalos) who filed nothing; and the crash report was written by the transporting officer (Jones).

---

★★★ 5. MORE CONTROL-NUMBER AND TIME DISAGREEMENTS

ItemCHP 555TR-130DS-367 / report
Crash time2029—20:20 / 20:46
Time of violation/arrest—215020:29 · 2044
DL numberF5244243F6244243F5244243
Case no.2026-00034514agency 20-348142026-00034514
Vehicle colourBROWN—TAN
InsuranceNOT PROVIDEDInsurance ☒ N—

The TR-130 puts the violation at 2150 — 81 minutes after the 2029 crash, and ~66 min after the DS-367's 2044 arrest time. Four different times for one arrest across the set.

Also on CHP p1: DIGITAL MEDIA: YES — so body-cam/MVARS exists. And REFER TO NARRATIVE unticked for mechanical defects.

Location pinned: 34.14946054868674, -117.252412886222.

---

★★ 6. THE COUNTERPARTY, NOW IDENTIFIED

Party 02 — Gwendolyn Daniella Ruiz-Gonzalez, DOB 02/14/2003 (23), 720 N Lincoln St, Redlands; 2020 Nissan Juke, black, plate 8PDR182, VIN 3N1CP5CV0LL484517, AAA-insured (CAA 184166695); travelling south; vehicle MAJOR damage; airbag deployed; towed at owner's request. Plus one passenger, pain to right arm.

Note: Moya's report calls it "a Nissan kick" — it is a Nissan Juke.

---

ASSESSMENT — WHAT THIS DOCUMENT DOES

It cuts both ways, and you need to know both.

AGAINST him: it is the first independent finding of fault + a speeding factor, from an officer who is not the arresting officer. Two injured people in the car he hit. A "high rate of speed" rear-end.

FOR him — and this is the weight of it:

1. The state's own crash report documents a violent collision with airbag deployment and major damage, and lists him as uninjured — while two others were hurt. That is the strongest Hughey exhibit yet: the collision was plainly significant, yet nobody assessed him.

2. The probable-cause chain runs through an absent officer (Avalos), with a blank sworn narrative and a blank observation block behind it.

3. *"Did not see the vehicle" + mandatory corrective lenses + officer noted glasses + never checked if worn = one innocent explanation covering the crash cause and the FST failure.*

4. Digital media confirmed to exist — the bodycam is real and findable.

5. Everything now has an independent, reviewable document behind it — including a review date (07/02/2026) showing the file sat for months.

Revised ranked attack — this report promotes items 2 and 3 to the front:

1. Suppression — blank sworn narrative + blank observation block + no observed driving + no warrant + no forced-draw tick + consent unproven. Avalos is the missing witness.

2. ★ The injury asymmetry — CHP says 2 injured, neither is him; airbag deployed, major damage, jail not hospital. Hughey.

3. ★ "Did not see" + Restriction B — one mechanism (vision) explains the crash and the FSTs. Beats the speeding finding.

4. Title 17 chain — three non-identical custody copies, mismatched kit numbers, expired tube, triple credential.

5. VGN + convergence failure.

6. Control-number and time chaos across five instruments.

Documents to demand now (hearing 18 Nov):

⚠️ Deadline flag: the TR-130 sets court 08/17/26 at 8:00 AM — i.e. already past (today is mid-Nov 2026) — with "ACT BY THIS DATE TO AVOID A WARRANT OR ADDED FEES." Confirm with the clerk (909-384-1888) whether the arraignment happened and whether anything is outstanding. The DMV hearing (18 Nov) is separate and still live.

Linked from: DUI Case